Natural regeneration in dry forest: state of research and limits
This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by us before publication.
Two large analyses show that tropical forests often recover faster after use than assumed, and that natural regeneration frequently outperforms planting. Both studies also state clear limits. This article sets out what follows for Finca Las Ramaditas and what is not yet documented.
Key figures
- After 20 years, regrowing tropical forests reach on average 78 percent of old-growth values (range 33 to 100 percent).[1]
- Biomass and species composition take more than 120 years to reach 90 percent of old-growth levels.[1]
- Across 133 studies, natural regeneration outperformed active planting by 34 to 56 percent for biodiversity.[2]
- Even restored sites remained 7 to 39 percent below intact reference forests for biodiversity.[2]
As of 14 November 2026.
Restoring a forest is usually associated with planting. Research from recent years gives a more differentiated picture: under suitable conditions forest recovers by itself, often with better results and at lower cost. The evidence comes from tropical forests in general, wet and dry. For the Gran Chaco specifically it is an indication, not proof.
How fast forest recovers by itself
An international team led by Lourens Poorter analysed data from 77 sites and more than 2,200 forest plots in Science in 2021. Twelve attributes were examined, from soil fertility to species composition. After 20 years, regrowing forests reach on average 78 percent of old-growth values, with a range of 33 to 100 percent depending on the attribute.
Recovery speed varies widely. Soil recovers in less than ten years, plant functioning in less than 25 years. Structure and species diversity take 25 to 60 years. Biomass and species composition only reach 90 percent of old-growth levels after more than 120 years.
Natural regeneration compared with planting
Renato Crouzeilles and colleagues compared 133 studies in Science Advances in 2017. Where rainfall, remaining forest cover and site history were accounted for, natural regeneration performed better than active planting: by 34 to 56 percent for biodiversity and by 19 to 56 percent for vegetation structure.
Limits of the findings
Both papers state their own limits. Natural regeneration is not the better choice everywhere. Where conditions are unsuitable or particular tree species are needed, planting remains necessary. The advantages apply mainly after low-intensity land use.
More importantly, even successfully restored sites stayed behind intact reference forests in the Crouzeilles analysis, by 7 to 39 percent for biodiversity. This gives a clear order of priority. Keeping existing forest standing achieves more than any later restoration.
What this means for Las Ramaditas
At Finca Las Ramaditas in Salta, Arkadia primarily protects existing dry forest. That matches the order of priority from the research.
Two points are open and are named here as open. First, young cattle belonging to a local family graze a delimited section at low stocking density with rotating paddocks, to keep scrub and fuel load down. This is managed use, not full exclusion of grazing. How forest regrowth develops under this grazing has not yet been documented by surveys of our own. Second, enrichment is planned for a 250-hectare section; the plan is being drawn up.
The baseline survey that is to serve as the reference is planned. Statements about regeneration success at Las Ramaditas will only be possible once that survey exists and has been repeated.
Sources
- Poorter et al., Science 374: Multidimensional tropical forest recovery (2021). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abh3629
- Crouzeilles et al., Science Advances 3: Ecological restoration success is higher for natural regeneration than for active restoration in tropical forests (2017). https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.1701345